Talk About Art! An exercise in Art Appreciation.



Alexander (Year 2): The Champion! 48 Points!!!

At the end of each of my lessons I devote 5-10 minutes to the 'Art Show'.... where we reflect on what we have achieved that day. Becoming an artist is as much about thinking and reflection as it is about doing. I want my students to be able to appreciate and discuss their own work and that of others.


Because of the number of students in each class, we usually focus on the art pieces that are going to be featured on the internet that week. (Every child has his/her work published at least once per term. Pieces are chosen randomly from the roll before the start of each lesson - this ensures that the kids know that I am not choosing pieces that I 'like best'!)

We start by looking at these 2 or 3 pieces and thinking of at least one thing that we think has been particularly well done. I encourage the students to talk about the techniques we used that day as well as the elements and principles of design. (Because my classes are a fun, after-school activity, these concepts are not formally taught, but it is amazing what they pick up and understand through discussion and modelling of language!) I always stress that we are not commenting on the picture we like best - we are looking for things that we think each artist has done well.
(This is particularly  important as there are frequently pieces by Prep students side-by-side with pieces by children in years 6 or 7! The children have no trouble at all understanding that we are not making comparisons. They go out of their way to find especially nice things to say about the littlies work :))

When I moved from a private website to a blog in August this year, I realized that it presented a wonderful opportunity for my students to share not only their work, but also their thoughts about their art, with a much broader audience! Art Appreciation in Real Life!!!!
So I started a 'Commenting Competition'!

The rules were fairly simple - You could comment on any art work on the blog. Only positive comments allowed. You could make as many comments as you liked.
I awarded points according to the quality of the comments made -
A simple "I like this picture" earned 1 point.
A comment that included one positive aspect of the picture, using relevant art terms and language, earned 2 points.
A comment that included 2 or more aspects, using relevant art language, earned 3 points.

The competition ran for 3 weeks, at the end of which I awarded a prize for the child with the most points from each class, and a prize for the overall winner from all 5 classes.

 I was really impressed with the way so many of the children entered into the spirit of the competition :) and was also pleased to note that the quality of their comments improved markedly over the period of the competition!!

WELL DONE KIDS!!

Jody said...

I love this idea, so jealous that you have time in the class to do this. I only have 30 min. once a week and it flies by!

PLASTIQUEM - Espe said...

I agree with you, reflection and self-assessment of students enriches the group that captions from a perspetiva constructive. Analyze the processes of creation and the end result of the work done to improve students' self-esteem and are able to solve problems. A good post. A hug and see you soon.

sallgood said...

Hi! Thanks for stopping by my blog- you're right, we DO have a lot in common! I'm now following your blog too- I'll enjoy seeing your artist's work, and we can occasionally commiserate about hauling our supplies! :D

Rina k6art.com said...

HI Elizabeth

Great idea! You teach art, encourage language and social skills AND build community. Great work!

Olga Mart. said...

A blog undoubtedly lovely! A Very Interesting workplaces.
Thanks for the recommendation.
Tea will visit whenever I can.

dmasse said...

Great way to reflect on the elements and develop skills in art criticism. Well done!

Pat said...

Hi Elizabeth!

I didn't realize you were teaching privately rather in a public school. Sounds like you have lots more opportunities than I do to have those very important conversations with the kids. I'm jealous! I read your comment on my blog about the bentwood boxes. When I was planning the Northwest Coast unit a few years back, I tried to create a project for each grade level that would be appropriate for their skill level. Like I sais in my post, I had been "gifted" a ton of bakery boxes that are easy to assemble. When looking through allof the books and resources I found on Pacific Northwest Coast tribal art, the bentwood boxes appeared to be a prominent form of carving. I knew my students like 3D projects and wouldn't be intimidated by having to draw on so many surfaces. If there is anything else you'd like to know about the project, feel free to ask.

:)Pat

Martina Bisbe said...

CONGRATULATIONS. I really like your work.
You´re also kindly invited to know about me at:
http://librosmundodiminuto.blogspot.com.es/
http://libroschatipan.blogspot.com.es/
http://www.facebook.com/marvibe.cuentos
Best Regards,
coleccionmundodiminuto@gmail.com
chatipan@gmail.com

Chesterbrook Academy Elementary said...

What an excellent idea.
It provides students with the opportunity to offer an opinion.

Φανή Παπ., Ζωγράφος said...

Thank you for visiting me!!!Interesting artwork and an interesting blog!!I like the Indigenous Australian art, I love their colours!!!Congratulations for your artwork! I'll watch with pleasure your blog. The strips on the fish, glistening little hearts shaped. Kisses from Greece.

Patience said...

I am so enjoying your blog, Elizabeth -- well done, and thanks so much for introducing yourself to me so that I had the opportunity to find it! Love your creative ideas here -- wonderful too that you can share these with your students, helping to make a positive impact upon their lives and create lifelong memories....! I do think the arts and arts education is so important to child development, yet unfortunately it's often terribly shortchanged in our modern society -- thanks for taking the time to share your talents with your local youth...! In any case I'm now a blog follower -- here's looking forward to future updates...!

The Clever Feather said...

Great idea! I love the point system, that really does help then expand their comments during the critique. I need to do this more in my classes, it's good for kids! Love it!

Eva said...

Hola Elizabeth!! desde España un abrazo muy fuerte no sabes la alegría que me ha dado ver tu mensaje. Ya tienes una seguidora más, yo empezaré un curso de Filosofía para niños de 3 a 6 años pero tus pautas para reflexionar me han parecido muy interesantes. Nosotros en Enero empezaremos un proyecto de arte y he visto que trabajas muy bien estos trabajos desde el punto de vista del niño me encanta tu bloc. Estaremos en contacto. Un abrazo de una compañera.

Post a Comment

Thank you for visiting Gr8 Art Fun!
We love it when you leave a comment - it tells us that you have enjoyed seeing our art as much as we have enjoyed creating it!!

Back to Top